1  Ann McInnes BLACK (1 Jul 1892 Fort William, Ontario, Canada – 1978)
   +  Hugh BOYLE (6 Apr 1884 Renfrew, Ontario, Canada – 1969 Port Arthur, Ontario, Canada)
      2  Robert Duncan BOYLE (12 Jul 1911 Fort William, Ontario, Canada – 17 May 1912 Fort William, Ontario, Canada)
      2  Thomasena Ann “Tommy” BOYLE (24 Mar 1913 South Porcupine, Ontario, Canada – )
         +  Edward Leonard MESSAGE (Apr 1911 Schreiber, Thunder Bay, Ontario, Canada – Aug 1964 North Bay, Ontario, Canada)
      2  Eleanor BOYLE (10 Feb 1915 South Porcupine, Ontario, Canada – Mar 1965)
         +  Thomas John FISCHER ( – Aug 1964 North Bay, Ontario, Canada)